Amazing martina mcbride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup

When that chilly evening hits and you just need something wonderfully comforting, nothing beats a bowl of rich, savory soup. I adore finding celebrity recipes because sometimes it’s fun to see what the stars rely on for an easy weeknight soup idea! Today, we’re tackling a special request: recreating martina mcbride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup. After years of teaching youngsters how to make dependable meals, I promise you this recipe is straightforward but delivers that hug-in-a-bowl flavor you’re hoping for. If you love this kind of satisfying, cheesy flavor, you might also enjoy my recipe for easy chicken enchiladas. Get ready for a truly delicious pot of comfort.

Why This Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup Is a Family Favorite

I truly believe that some recipes stick with you because they take simple, pantry-friendly ingredients and turn them into something extraordinary. This soup is that very definition! It’s hearty, it tastes like it simmered all day, and yet, we can get it on the table quickly. It’s become a requested staple in my house, much like these easy sheet pan mini meatloaf muffins.

Quick Dinner Soup Idea for Busy Nights

When I was teaching, I needed meals that worked fast. This soup is fantastic because it comes together in under an hour on the stovetop, making it a perfect choice when you need a satisfying dinner without a lot of fuss.

The Secret to the Signature Creamy Texture

What sets this soup apart from a standard chicken tortilla soup is that divine richness. It’s not just cream; it’s the combination of heavy cream AND cream cheese working together. That’s the magic behind Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup, giving it that luxurious, restaurant-style feel.

Gathering Ingredients for Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

When we gather ingredients for a faithful recreation like this Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup, accuracy really matters. We want that specific, comforting Tex Mex Soup vibe, which means sticking close to the plan! I always organize everything before I even turn on the burner, which keeps that cooking process smooth, just like how I organize my pantry staples when making homemade cream of chicken soup.

The Soup Base Components

We need that foundation first! Grab two cans of condensed soup—one cream of chicken and one cream of mushroom. Don’t skip the mushroom; it adds such a nice earthy depth. You’ll also need four cups of good chicken broth. Add in one can of black beans (always rinsed and drained well!) and one can of corn (drained). Finally, make sure you start with about two large cooked chicken breasts, shredded nicely.

Achieving Richness: Cream and Cheese

This is where the luxurious texture comes in! We’re using a full cup of heavy cream, which is key. Crucially, you need four ounces of cream cheese, and you must cut it into little cubes before you start. Those small cubes melt much faster and smoother into the broth. This cream cheese element is what elevates this to the signature creamy promise of Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup!

For Frying the Tortilla Strips

For the absolute crunch, pick up some plain corn tortillas. You’ll want to slice these very thinly before frying. You’ll need about an inch of vegetable oil in your skillet to get them perfectly golden and crispy. Remember, these are added right at the end, so prep them while your soup is simmering away!

Step-by-Step Instructions for Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

Alright, let’s get this delicious Tex Mex soup on the stove! I always find that having all my ingredients ready—mise en place, as the fancy chefs say—makes the actual cooking so much more relaxing. We’re working towards that perfect, balanced flavor profile, so take your time with these simple steps. If you are looking for a slightly simpler approach to this comfort food, you might check out my general easy tortilla soup recipe first!

Combining and Simmering the Base

First thing’s first: grab your big pot or Dutch oven. We’re going to toss in everything that can handle a little heat right now. That means the shredded chicken, both cans of condensed soup, the corn, the rinsed beans, the Ro-Tel, the chicken broth, the cumin, and the chili powder. Put that on the stovetop over medium heat. Just stir it occasionally to make sure nothing’s sticking to the bottom. We’re looking for it to come up to a nice, gentle simmer, then you can back the heat down low.

Melting the Cream Cheese for Smoothness

This is the fun part, where the soup gets its gorgeous texture! Once it’s simmering gently, we add the heavy cream and those cubed pieces of cream cheese. Now, listen to me closely here: You have to stir constantly until that cream cheese melts completely and everything looks smooth. If you let it boil once the cream is in, you risk it getting grainy! We don’t want that separation; we want silky perfection. Once it’s uniform, taste it and add salt and pepper until it tastes just right for you.

Preparing Crispy Tortilla Strips

While that soup is warming up nicely, let’s handle those crunchy toppings. Pour about an inch of vegetable oil into a skillet and get it medium-high. You must fry the tortilla strips in small batches. Don’t crowd the pan, or they’ll just steam instead of crisping up! Once they are golden brown—and this happens fast—scoop them out with a slotted spoon immediately and place them on a plate lined with paper towels to drain off that excess oil. A little pinch of salt right after they come out of the oil makes all the difference. Trust me, these homemade strips are way better than any bag you can buy. If you like frying things until they’re perfect, you’ll want to see my tips for crispy fried potatoes!

Tips for the Best Chicken Tortilla Soup Experience

Even though this Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup is simple, a few extra touches can really push it into the “Best Chicken Tortilla Soup” category! I’ve learned over the years that the little details—the things you don’t always write down—are what make a recipe truly dependable for company. It’s about controlling the flavor and the texture, something I focused on both in the classroom and here in my kitchen.

Flavor Boosts for Your Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

First off, use the best chicken broth you can find. If you use a watery broth, you’ll end up with a thin soup, and we want richness here! We relied on good broth when I taught my kids how to make a perfect homemade brown gravy, and the rule applies here too. Secondly, don’t stop at the cumin and chili powder! If you feel it needs just a little extra kick—and I often do, depending on the Rotel I buy—add just a dash or two of your favorite hot sauce right before you turn the heat off. It deepens that warmth beautifully.

Making Tortilla Strips Healthier

Frying is delicious, there’s no denying that wonderful flavor, but sometimes we want to skip the extra oil. If you want crispy strips without the skillet, try this easy trick. Cut your corn tortillas just as we did before, toss them lightly with a teaspoon of olive oil—don’t drown them!—and spread them in a single layer on a baking sheet. Pop them into a 375-degree oven for about 10 to 12 minutes, turning halfway through. They come out nearly as satisfyingly crunchy. Of course, if you want tips on keeping your chicken juicy before you even shred it, check out my thoughts on the best chicken marinade!

Serving Suggestions for This Creamy Spicy Soup

You’ve made the soup, and now it’s time for the fun part: dressing it up! This is where your bowl of creamy spicy soup transforms into a real showstopper, just like the best Tex Mex soup ideas you see at restaurants. Don’t skimp on the toppings; they add texture and freshness that balances that rich base perfectly. I always put everything out family-style so everyone can customize their own bowl.

Here are the essentials that I always set on the table:

• Shredded Monterey Jack Cheese (get a good melting kind!)
• Diced fresh avocado for cool creaminess
• A dollop of sour cream
• Fresh cilantro, chopped fine

And of course, don’t forget those crispy tortilla strips we fried up! A bowl of this, loaded high, is pure comfort. Speaking of creamy comfort, if you ever need a different option, my recipe for easy creamy white chicken chili is always a hit, too.

Storage and Reheating Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

One of the best things about making a big pot of soup is having leftovers! This Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup stores beautifully in the refrigerator for about three to four days. We usually store ours right in our big Dutch oven with a tight lid, or transfer it to airtight containers. But here’s my biggest word of advice for reheating this creamy soup:

When you are ready to warm it up the next day, do it slowly over medium-low heat. You absolutely must stir it constantly, especially as the broth starts to warm up. As we talked about before, the heavy cream and cream cheese can separate or get oily if they get too hot. Never let it come to a rolling boil! Just get it hot enough so it’s steaming gently, and it will be just as rich as the night you made it. If reheating requires you to sneak some of my classic creamy ham salad for lunch instead, well, I won’t tell anyone!

Adaptations: Making Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup in the Slow Cooker

I know life gets hectic, and sometimes a stovetop recipe just isn’t going to cut it. That’s why I always love figuring out how to adapt my favorite comfort food recipes for the slow cooker. Luckily, this Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup is fantastic for that method too! You can just toss everything—the chicken, the canned goods, the broth, and all those wonderful spices—right into the crockpot. Set it low for about six hours or high for three hours.

The only thing you have to remember is timing for the creaminess. Because we don’t want that heavy cream or the cream cheese sitting in there for eight hours straight, you need to wait until the final 30 minutes of cooking time. Stir in that cream cheese until it melts perfectly smooth, then gently stir in the heavy cream. It keeps the dairy from breaking down while still giving you that incredible, rich texture when dinner time rolls around. If you’re looking for more easy meals made while you’re busy, check out my recipe for slow cooker chicken and dumplings—it’s another one that uses the set-it-and-forget-it method beautifully!

Frequently Asked Questions About This Comfort Food Chicken Soup

I always get the same types of questions once folks start making this rich soup for the first time! Since this Comfort Food Chicken Soup is so satisfying, people naturally want to tweak it to fit exactly what they have on hand. Cooking should be flexible, but some parts of this recipe, especially those dairy components, need a little respect. If you’re wondering how you can make substitutions or fix common hiccups, look no further. These are the questions I get most often!

Can I make this soup vegetarian?

That’s a great question! You absolutely can adapt this recipe, though it will change the spirit slightly from the original Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup. To make it vegetarian, you’ll skip the shredded chicken entirely. Instead, boost the veggies! I recommend adding about two cans of white beans—cannellini or great northern—and perhaps even tossing in some diced sweet potato or zucchini when you add the broth. You’ll still get great body from the cream cheese and cream, making it a wonderful How to Make Creamy Tortilla Soup variation!

My soup separated after adding the cream. What went wrong?

Oh, that’s the most common dairy disaster! It usually means the temperature spiked too high. Remember when I said, “Do not let the soup boil once the cream is added”? That’s the golden rule here. When the heavy cream hits the hot broth alongside the cheese, if the mixture boils vigorously, the fat can separate from the liquid, and you get that slightly curdled or oily look. If this happens, turn the heat to the absolute lowest setting, maybe even take it off the heat entirely for a minute, and whisk vigorously. Adding a splash of cold water or fresh broth can sometimes help bring it back together! If you are looking for another great creamy dish, try my creamy ricotta egg toast!

What is the best way to shred the chicken?

If you’re cooking your own chicken breasts ahead of time just for this recipe, I have a trick for super easy shredding. Once the chicken is cooked and cooled just enough that you can handle it, toss it into your stand mixer bowl fitted with the paddle attachment. Run it on low speed for about 30 seconds! It shreds perfectly evenly every time. If you don’t have a mixer, the classic method works just fine: put the warm chicken in a wide bowl, take two forks, and pull them against each other until you get that fluffy texture you want. It’s the best way to prep for our Comfort Food Chicken Soup!

Nutritional Snapshot of Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

Now, I always tell my grandkids that recipes are about flavor and love first, that’s always true. But for those of you who like to keep track of what you’re eating—and I certainly do when I’m planning meals for the whole family—it’s helpful to have a general idea of what’s in that big, delicious bowl of this Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup.

The estimates below are based on the recipe using the ingredients listed, and they account for one bowl serving size. Keep in mind that the final numbers will change a bit depending on how much oil you use when frying your tortilla strips or exactly how much cheese you pile on top! These figures are just a baseline to help you gauge things, much like giving a rough estimate when I plan out sides for those easy creamy chicken enchiladas.

Here is what you can generally expect from one serving:

• Serving Size: 1 bowl
• Calories: 450
• Fat: 28g
• Saturated Fat: 15g
• Carbohydrates: 25g
• Sugar: 8g
• Protein: 28g
• Sodium: 750mg

It’s a filling, satisfying meal rich in protein! Just remember, these are my best estimates for this classic, comfort food chicken soup, not lab results!

Share Your Martina McBride’s Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup Creations

Well, friend, that’s the whole journey from the pantry shelf to the dinner table for this wonderful Martina McBride’s creamy chicken tortilla soup. I truly hope you loved making it as much as I enjoy sharing it with you! For me, the greatest joy in the kitchen is hearing about how a recipe worked for your family. Did the cream cheese melt perfectly for you? Did your kids devour those homemade tortilla strips?

I put so much care into making sure every recipe here on Cooking by Carla is dependable, especially things like this classic Celebrity Favorite Soup. So, if you followed along and enjoyed this rich, Tex Mex delight, please don’t be shy! Let me know how you found the spice level or what your absolute favorite topping was.

Scroll down, leave a star rating right there on the recipe card, and tell me all about it in the comments below. Whether you try it next Tuesday or save it for a special weekend meal, I can’t wait to hear how your version turned out. Looking forward to connecting with you—you can always read a little more about my philosophy on simple home cooking over on my About Page!

Print